When I first started Crossfit I did what I normally do with any new interest...started researching and reading about it. A few of the first few things I came across were straight from the Crossfit HQ website. The founder of Crossfit, Greg Glassman, wrote about what is known as "virtuosity" in the sport of gymnastics and how those participating in Crossfit should strive towards this...epseicially those new to the sport.
Glassman's definition of virtuosity as it applies to Crossfit
Virtuosity, though, is a different beast altogether. Virtuosity is defined in gymnastics as “performing the common uncommonly well.” Unlike risk and originality, virtuosity is elusive, supremely elusive. It is, however, readily recognized by audience as well as coach and athlete. But more importantly, more to my point, virtuosity is more than the requirement for that last tenth of a point; it is always the mark of true mastery (and of genius and beauty).
--Fundamentals, Virtuosity, and Mastery
As Glassman says in his article, just completing a routine does not award 10 out of 10 possible points - only 9.7. The last 3 tenths of a point come from performing the routine and included skills with exceptional mastery. In gymnastics, every competitor will finish, but the real question is who can finish and demonstrate the technical prowess and perfection that will warrant those last 0.3 points.
Crossfit on the other hand isn't geared towards rewarding technical excellence at all. At least Crossfit the sport isn't and Crossfit the workout program only emphasizes virtuosity if a coach is of that mindset. The sport of Crossfit is primarily about whose time is fastest, who can lift the most, and reps versus no reps.
Many may think of a possible recent example with the Josh Bridges incident during this year's 16.4 Open workout. Being the elite athlete that he is, he had to submit a video of his workout and after being named the winner of that week's workout the internet exploded with accusations of no reps on his deadlifts...which was in part supported by Crossfit HQ. Was this a case of Crossfit HQ docking him for a lack of virtuosity?....Nope. It was merely the enforcement of a rep versus no rep for the actual movement based on preset standards.
So what might be an example of rewarding virtuosity in Crossfit? Let's look at 16.3 and the bar muscle up.
While it was super exciting to see a thousand videos of people kicking and flailing their way to their #firstbarmuscleup - I would not say their execution of the skill demonstrated mastery...obviously. Not to bring anyone down, but we're looking for as close to perfection of the movement as possible. For the bar muscle up that might include, straight legs that don't separate, pointed toes (if shoeless), almost no bend in the arms when coming over the bar, smooth kipping motions, and hey...why not stick the landing when you come off before running to those light power snatches?
Perhaps an elite athlete who submitted a video of their beautifully performed 16.3 workout would get a 5% - 10% virtuosity bump in their score. That might be worth it enough for people to actually strive towards this technical mastery. (Bridges got a 15% reduction in reps as a major penalty so this would be in line with that scoring system)
Should Crossfit Reward Virtuosity?
At this point you're probably thinking "Seriously?...Stick the landing? Ok new guy, go back to your Box and I'll show you where you can stick your landing. That is just going to slow me down".
Well that is part of what virtuosity is. Should your snatch also be judged on form and if you take a couple wobbly steps as you stand up? Should your deadlift reps be reduced if you are one of those people who tend to round their back a little as the reps go on? If you do 30 beautiful muscleups should you be rewarded with 5 extra if performed with perfect form and finess? Perhaps your Diane time would be reduced if you do strict handstand push-ups with good form vice kipping?
Personally I think it would be cool to incorporate a bonus for virtuosity at the Regional or Games level but I don't think it would work in the Open. Also I don't believe there should be a penalty for less than virtuous form as Crossfit the sport is still primarily geared towards rep completion and "for time" workouts.
Ultimately Glassman spelled it out correctly, athletes new to the sport should strive for virtuosity but typically don't....which is often their downfall and leads to easier injury. Striving towards this technical mastery actually creates efficiency of movement and will, in the long run, make you faster and able to complete more reps with less energy. However, I would venture to guess that this is not emphasized enough in Crossfit affiliate boxes. I physically cringe every time I see someone flail up to their first kipping muscle up. All I see is what part of their shoulder will eventually tear and want to shout at them to get a strict muscle up first...but I'm not Level 1 certified and not a Crossfit coach.
I'm just the crossfit new guy.